Pie Season is Here! The Best Thanksgiving Pies Around RVA

If you’re on the hunt for the best pie in the greater Richmond area — whether you want a flaky classic apple, a special-order pecan for Thanksgiving, a vegan coconut cream, or a savory hand pie — you’re in good company. I’ve sampled (via menus & local reports) and pulled together the top pie shops and bakeries in Midlothian and Richmond so you can get to the good stuff fast.

Top Picks (why they’re worth the trip):

For the Love of Flour (Midlothian area) — A cozy boutique bakery with rotating offerings. They list pies among their daily lineup, and it’s a great local pick for unique flavors and smaller orders.
Wegmans Midlothian — While it’s a grocery store bakery rather than a boutique-only pie shop, their bakery is divine and does include whole pies/crostata (see their “Pies/Crostata” section) and it’s very convenient for quick pickup and reliable flavors.
Proper Pie Co. (Richmond) — The iconic pie shop in RVA. Proper Pie is known for both sweet fruit pies and creative savory pies (think hand pies with bold fillings). Seasonal flavors roll through their menu, so check their socials before you go.
WPA Bakery (Richmond) — A neighborhood institution with slices and whole pies, plus vegan and gluten‐free options. Their special-order pie list is long (apple, shoo-fly, pecan, peanut butter, chocolate chess, and more) — ideal for parties and holidays.
Minglewood Bake Shop, Shyndigz, Pies & Cakes Bakery, RVA Bakehouse — Each of these offers seasonal or made-to-order pies and is worth a check when you want something specific or a slightly different style (artisan crusts, modern flavor twists, or cake-pie hybrids).

How to choose the right shop:

For a holiday centerpiece: Pick a place that accepts special orders — WPA and many bakeries will make whole pies to spec if you order in advance.
For everyday sweet or a slice now: Proper Pie and WPA often have slices or ready-made whole pies; grocery bakery (Wegmans) is good for last-minute pickup.
Dietary needs: WPA lists vegan & gluten-free options; always call ahead to confirm.
Savory pies / hand pies: Proper Pie specializes in savory hand pies as well as sweet pies — great when you want a more filling option.

Quick ordering tips:

Call ahead for holidays or weekends — many small shops sell out!
Special orders: Ask about lead times and pickup windows (some bakeries take 48-72 hours for custom pies).
Social media: Follow their Instagram or Facebook for flavor drops and daily menus — most of these bakeries announce pie flavors there.

Whether you’re picking up a pie for a gathering, grabbing a slice after work, or ordering something special for dessert, the Richmond / Midlothian area has some strong options. From boutique artisan pies to convenient bakery options at a supermarket, you’ve got flexibility. Happy pie hunting!